Old tattoo to blame for woman’s ‘cancer’
Doctors in Australia suspected that a woman had a type of cancer called lymphoma, but they were stunned when they put her enlarged lymph node under a microscope — and instead found black tattoo pigment from 15 years ago to which her immune system was just now reacting.
They recounted the strange case in a report released Monday in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine.
The 30-year-old woman had come in with small lumps under her arms, which had been there for two weeks. A body scan showed even more enlarged lymph nodes in her chest, including near the roots of her lungs.
“Ninety-nine times out of 100, (this) will be lymphoma,” said Dr. Christian Bryant, a hematologist at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in Sydney. Bryant is one of the woman’s doctors.
In the case of the Australian woman, whose name was not released, her lymph nodes were inflamed because of a reaction to the old tattoo ink, not due to cancer cells. Doctors removed a lymph node from her armpit and found a cluster of immune cells that were loaded with black pigment. The woman had a 15-year-old tattoo covering her back, and there was a smaller, more recent one on her shoulder.
“The skin has its own immune cells that are always surveilling the skin,” said Dr. Bill Stebbins, director of cosmetic dermatology at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, who was not involved in the report.
Once these immune cells found the tattoo pigment, a foreign substance, they ingested it and traveled from the skin to the lymph nodes over a period of years.
“The pigment is too large for these cells to eat and digest,” Stebbins said. “That’s why they’re still there many years later.”
But why the woman had a reaction 15 years after her tattoo is a mystery. Something set off the immune cells, but her doctors couldn’t pin down what that trigger might be, Bryant said. The patient noted that her tattoos would occasionally itch, but only for a few days each month. The type of inflammatory response found in her lymph nodes, called a granuloma, was not found in her skin.
Bryant and his colleagues had never seen anything quite like it. Other reports have described swollen, pigmented lymph nodes that were mistaken for melanoma, but this is the first time they had heard of a case with lymph nodes deep enough to fit the picture of lymphoma.
“I think there’s absolutely no way to know how common it is,” Bryant said. “Most people who have tattoos have absolutely no problems.”
“We do a lot of tattoo removal with lasers in our practice, and sometimes we see people developing allergic reactions to the ink,” said Dr. Bruce Katz, a fellow with the American Academy of Dermatology and director of the Juva Skin and Laser Center in Manhattan. Katz was not involved with the new report.
But these reactions are usually to red pigments, not black.
In the US, nearly four in 10 millennials have tattoos, according to a Pew Research Center report. Among Generation X, slightly fewer have tattoos: about 32%. For baby boomers, that number drops to 15%.
For those looking to get inked, Katz said, it’s crucial to do your research: Make sure the artist is reputable, get references from clients, and ensure that they are using disposable needles and unopened ink to prevent infections.
Stebbins said it’s important for people to be aware of these rare complications because people might not realize that a tattoo can cause inflammation years later. “It’s important for physicians to be aware of a tattoo history,” he said.
Tattoos are often hidden from view, meaning a doctor may not notice them right away. Almost three-quarters of Americans with tattoos usually hide them under clothing, according to the Pew report.
There are other potential complications of tattoos, including infections and other inflammatory reactions. One Texas man even died after swimming with a new tattoo, which became infected with a bacterium found in coastal waters.
But the Australian woman’s case is far less serious. The last time Bryant saw her, the swollen lymph nodes had subsided.
“It’s not going to cause this lady any major problems,” Bryant said, “which means we’re allowed to be interested without feeling sad.”
The hematologist added, “My job’s often not like that.”