Watch Live: Judiciary Committee to debate articles of impeachment against Pres. Donald Trump
Weather closings and delays

Scott Sica pleads guilty to first-degree murder of Jonesville Police Sgt. Greg Martin

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Data pix.

PicMonkey fadsdCollage

YADKINVILLE, N.C. -- Scott Vincent Sica, the Florida man charged with murdering Jonesville Police Sgt. Greg Martin in 1996, agreed Tuesday to plead guilty for the first-degree murder of Martin back in 1996.

Sica entered the plea in Yadkin County court Tuesday morning.

The state will no longer seek the death penalty in exchange for Sica agreeing to plead guilty.

Sica also pleaded guilty to attempted robbery with a dangerous weapon.

Sica was sentenced to life in prison without parole. He was also sentenced to 117-150 days for the attempted robbery charge.

The state dismissed three charges, including conspiring to commit robbery with a dangerous weapon and two counts of possession of a stolen vehicle.

Sica, of Cape Coral, Fla., was arrested on Oct. 3, 2012, in connection with the 1996 shooting death of Sgt. Martin.

Martin was shot six times on Oct. 5, 1996, during a traffic stop on I-77 near exit 82 in Jonesville. He was 30 years old and married to Lisa Martin. He had a stepson, daughter and 6-month-old son.

In January 2013, Brian Eugene Whittaker, 37, of Cape Coral, Fla., and Marc Peterson Olroyd, 42, of Rockwood, Tenn., were also charged in the case.

Sgt. Martin's daughter Brittany said the plea agreement was a big step for her family. "Right now it's kind of relief and finally justice being served after so long, and it's just a joy. Now it's Daddy's turn to finally rest."

Brittany was only six years old when her father was killed, but her family helps her remember what he was like. "He's the best man you probably could have ever known. Society's really missed on a great chance to meet a great guy," she added.

She said justice was finally served. "One door finally gets to shut and we get to open the next stage of our life and move on. Been dealing with this going on 18 years. It's like you get to start over and you get to have a little more peace in life."

On the night he was killed, Sgt. Martin noticed Sica and Whittaker in a red pickup truck and thought they were acting suspiciously. Investigators later determined they were about to rob a local restaurant.

When Sgt. Martin pulled over the truck on the interstate, he told dispatch he was making a traffic stop. Highway Patrol Trooper Van Tate asked if Martin needed assistance and agreed to come help out.

In the meantime, Sica and Whittaker got out of the truck while Martin searched it. Investigators say Sica pulled out a gun and shot the officer six times in the head.

In court, a detective said Tate arrived at the scene only a few minutes later, but his friend and fellow law enforcement officer was already dead.

Tate told FOX8, "Today was a good day. Today, Greg got his justice. Greg's family got their justice. And I got my closure."

“It's always been in the back of our minds," said life-long resident Regina Adkins.  "Always looking over your shoulder and wondering who, when and why. I'm very glad justice has been served.”

He remembered often getting coffee with Sgt. Martin and inviting him over for dinner. "When Greg was working he'd come by. My wife and I would be home, we'd have him come in and sup with us. After all this happened those days were gone."

Tate was emotional while he talked about his friend. Both had infant sons at the time of Martin's death.

"God's been good,” he said. “I am so blessed and so fortunate to have the family I have who stood by me. Greg's family's been strong. They got the justice they wanted, we know what happened now, and that's the biggest blessing of all. We've all got closure."

Detective Ron Perry presented most of the evidence to court Tuesday. He was an SBI investigator at the time of the murder. When he retired in 2003, he agreed to work part-time with local law enforcement to work solely on the Martin case, which was still unsolved.

The detective described Sica, Whittaker and Olroyd's armed robbery sprees. He said they would test drive a vehicle at a car dealership and then swap out or steal the key, later returning to steal the vehicle off the dealership lot. Sica and Whittaker would allegedly use the stolen car to rob a restaurant or bank. They'd dump the car and Olroyd would pick them up in his green truck as a getaway vehicle.

The red truck Sica and Whittaker were driving the night of the murder was stolen from a Chevy dealer in West Virginia. They switched out the key for one of Olroyd's green pickup keys.

All these years later, Perry finally tied the pieces together with that key, fingerprints and a handful of people who came forward with information.

Whittaker and Olroyd were not in court Tuesday. They are still facing charges for the murder.

Data pix.


  • FaithC

    No death penalty?? Why? Is the DA afraid to take this case to court. Why a plea deal. This man deserves the death penalty. now the tax payers have to keep this sorry POS alive in prison for the rest of his sorry life.
    The only way I would be ok with that is if they made him and others like him work at hard labor every day until they worked them to death.

    • blake

      You’re an idiot the attorney done what he was supposed to do. Make sure he was put in jail. Killing him cost more than keeping him alive will. Not to mention the possible of mistrial, hung jury, him still getting a non guilty verdict(this has happened). He’s in jail now and he’ll stay there until he dies. You’re no better a person than him if you want to have someone kill him. Pathetic if you ask me, people yell and scream for the death penalty but wouldn’t do it himself.

    • Blah

      It does cost more for all the appeals that he would have received than it would to keep him in prison for life.

    • Chuck

      Now you know if they were worked to death they would have lawyers lined up around the planet to sue the state for cruel and unusual punishment… He took a plea deal, there shouldn’t have been a plea deal he admitted to doing it and they had the evidence! He DIDN”T deserve a plea deal, Greg didn’t get a plea for his life!

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.