Paterno family: Freeh report ‘factually wrong’
STATE COLLEGE, Pa. (CNN) — The family of the late Joe Paterno released a report Sunday morning that absolved the coaching great of blame in the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal.
They also said a prior review commissioned by Penn State University was “factually wrong, speculative and fundamentally flawed.”
Former Attorney General Dick Thornburgh put together the new report, the Paterno family said in a written statement.
“The experts determined that the conclusions of the (university) report are based on raw speculation and unsupported opinion — not facts and evidence,” Thornburgh said, according to the statement.
The statement said Paterno never attempted to hide any information or impede any investigation into Sandusky’s activities while using Penn State facilities.
The university responded to the report, saying Freeh had been tasked with conducting an internal review to identify failures in the school’s response to allegations.
“It is understandable and appreciated that people will draw their own conclusions and opinions from the facts uncovered in the Freeh report,” Penn State said in a written statement.
The school had acted on most of the 119 recommendations made in the report, the statement said.
After Sandusky was arrested in November 2011, the university fired Paterno and funded a review of the scandal led by former FBI Director Louis Freeh.
Freeh’s 267-page review was released in July 2012 and blamed Paterno, former university President Graham Spanier, suspended Athletic Director Tim Curley and ex-Vice President Gary Schultz for allegedly taking part in a cover-up to avoid bad publicity.
The family disputed that, saying the “allegation is false” that Paterno participated in a conspiracy.
The Paterno family review also skewered the Freeh report for failing to interview key witnesses, allowing some to testify anonymously, and using an incomplete string of e-mails for evidence. Most of the e-mails from that time are unavailable, the family said.
Freeh’s team concluded that the school’s top administrators had “empowered” Sandusky, the former defensive coordinator for the football team, to continue his abuse. The report said the panel interviewed more than 430 witnesses.
A lawyer for one of Sandusky’s victims said Sunday that Paterno should have taken action after reports of Sandusky’s behavior.
The family’s complaints about witnesses and e-mails “do not erase the shocking and striking documents which Freeh did uncover and which form an unassailable finding made by Mr. Freeh that Joe Paterno tragically had knowledge in 1998 and again in 2001 that Jerry Sandusky was a threat, which was never dealt with properly by the former Penn State coach,” said Thomas Kline, attorney for Victim No. 5 in the Sandusky trial.
In an online letter to Penn State current and former players, Paterno’s widow, Sue, wrote on Friday: “The Freeh report failed and if it is not challenged and corrected, nothing worthwhile will have come from these tragic events.”
The family, she said, wants a full record of what happened.
The university panicked after the Freeh report was released, she claimed, and Penn State’s board of trustees should have challenged the report.
She told the players that they — and his family — were Joe Paterno’s legacy, not a report.
She also criticized the Freeh report’s depiction of her husband.
“When the Freeh report was released last July, I was as shocked as anyone by the findings and by Mr. Freeh’s extraordinary attack on Joe’s character and integrity. I did not recognize the man Mr. Freeh described,” she said.
The university’s board of trustees fired Paterno following a 46-year career because, it said, his “decision to do his minimum legal duty and not to do more to follow up constituted a failure of leadership.”
In July 2012, the NCAA hit Penn State with some of the most severe penalties it has ever imposed, including a $60 million fine.
The governing body of major college sports also vacated Penn State’s football wins dating back to 1998, the year when allegations that Sandusky was abusing children were first made. That penalty removed Paterno from the top of the list of Division I college football’s winningest coaches. Paterno died in January 2012.
Sandusky, who ran a charity for disadvantaged children after he retired in 1999, was convicted last June on 45 counts of child sex abuse. In October, the 68-year-old former coach was sentenced to 30 to 60 years in prison.
Spanier, Curley and Schultz face charges stemming from the Sandusky scandal, including perjury, conspiracy and endangering the welfare of children. All three are awaiting court dates and have said they are innocent, according to their lawyers.
By Steve Almasy, CNN. CNN’s Susan Candiotti contributed to this report.