Court grants stay of ‘excruciating’ execution

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Russell Bucklew

MISSOURI¬†— A three-judge panel of the U.S. 8th Circuit Court of Appeals has granted a stay of execution for a Missouri death row inmate whose rare birth defect, his lawyers argued, would have made his death an “excruciating” process.

Russell Bucklew had been scheduled to die at 1:01 a.m. Wednesday at Eastern Reception, Diagnostic and Correctional Center in Bonne Terre, Missouri. It would have been the first execution since Oklahoma botched a procedure last month.

In their request for a stay, filed Tuesday, Bucklew’s attorneys said he could suffer a “prolonged and excruciating execution” because of his birth defect, known as cavernous hemangioma.

A U.S. District Court judge on Monday declined to stay the execution, and declined a request the procedure be videotaped.

But the three-judge panel of the 8th Circuit Court voted 2-1 to grant the stay late Tuesday.

The court’s order said, “Bucklew’s unrebutted medical evidence demonstrates the requisite sufficient likelihood of unnecessary pain and suffering beyond the constitutionally permissible amount inherent in all executions.”

The Missouri Attorney General’s office responded by immediately filing a motion Tuesday night asking the entire 8th Circuit Court to hold a hearing on the issue. The court has 11 active and four senior judges, according to the court website. No date for such a hearing has been set.

Bucklew, who turned 46 last week, is already in pain, as his condition includes unstable tumors in his head and neck, causing him to bleed regularly from his mouth, nose, eyes and ears, said defense attorney Cheryl Pilate.

Dr. Joel Zivot of Emory University filed an affidavit in the case saying that Bucklew’s airway is so “severely compromised and obstructed,” especially when he’s lying flat, that it could easily be ruptured, raising the risk that Bucklew could choke or suffocate.

“If you touch it, it bleeds,” Zivot wrote of Bucklew’s airway.

In 1997, a jury convicted Bucklew of first-degree murder, kidnapping and first-degree burglary and recommended the death sentence, court documents show.

He was accused of fatally shooting his ex-girlfriend’s presumed new boyfriend, Michael Sanders, and firing at Sanders’ son, 6, before kidnapping Stephanie Ray Pruitt. After raping his ex-girlfriend, he became involved in a gunfight with authorities, during which Bucklew and a Missouri state trooper were injured, according to court documents.

Controversy over lethal injections has been brewing in recent years after European manufacturers, including the Denmark-based manufacturer of pentobarbital, banned U.S. prisons from using their drugs in executions. In 2009, the U.S.-based manufacturer of sodium thiopental, a drug also commonly used in executions, stopped making the painkiller.

Many states have scrambled to find substitutes from overseas or have used American-based compounding pharmacies to create substitutes.

Attorneys for death row inmates in several states have flooded the court system, arguing that correctional facilities’ secrecy over where and how they obtain drugs is unconstitutional and violates the Eighth Amendment’s “cruel and unusual” punishment clause.

Last month, Oklahoma used a new three-drug injection protocol to execute convicted murderer and rapist Clayton Lockett, but his vein collapsed, and he died of an apparent heart attack. A full investigation and autopsy results are still pending, but witnesses said they saw Lockett struggling to speak as he convulsed and writhed on the gurney.

Previously, Oklahoma inmate Michael Lee Wilson said during his January execution, “I feel my whole body burning.” Wilson was executed using a cocktail that included pentobarbital, as was Texas’ Jose Luis Villegas, who also complained of a burning sensation during his April execution.

Also in Texas, Robert James Campbell’s attorneys challenged the state’s plan to administer pentobarbital to their client. A federal court stayed his execution last week, not because of the drugs Texas planned to use but because his defense team deserved more time to make the case that Campbell was intellectually disabled.

On Monday, the Georgia Supreme Court weighed in on the issue, reversing a stay of execution for inmate Warren Lee Hill after his attorneys argued last year that a statute keeping the compounders of lethal injection drugs “a confidential state secret” was unconstitutional.

“We hold that it is not,” Justice P. Harris Hines wrote in the 33-page majority opinion.

He said the reason for keeping such information private is “obvious, including avoiding the risk of harassment or some other form of retaliation from persons related to the prisoners or from others in the community who might disapprove of the execution as well as simply offering those willing to participate whatever comfort or peace of mind that anonymity might offer.”


  • FaithC

    Should we feel sorry for him? I don’t think so!! He felt nothing when he did what he did. Put this scum down like you would any mad dog.

  • Ree

    When car accident victims etc are in danger of further injury, are in excruciating pain etc. the hospitals/caregivers will place them in a drug induced coma. Isnt this a plausible idea for death row inmates?

  • Paula Jackson

    Use PROPAFAL!! They won’t feel a thing, and it puts them out of OUR MISERY!!! We should not be concerned about these POS animals, that have done UNSPEAKABLE things to innocent people.

  • Linda

    Why is there so much concern for this horrible human – he did not give any consideration to the suffering of those he raped and killed !
    Form a firing squad – get it over with !

  • gena byrd

    This is an absolute outrage! What kind of consideration did this piece of scum give to the suffering of the man he shot to death, the woman he raped, or the 6 year old child he shot at?? NONE!!!! This is exactly why people don’t hesitate to kill. There are no real consequences! They get free room & board, free meals, & they have no bills to pay. They no longer have any real responsibilities. Who makes these laws??? Am I the only one who sees how completely backward this is?? He MURDERED someone! And he deserves some kind of sympathy??? HOW????

  • Suzi

    If lethal injection will cause him such pain, then they should hang him, or use the gas chamber…SImple…

  • Bobby Ward

    Who Cares!!!!HE killed someone….You think they wanted to Die…HELL he needs to die!!!Not waste of time in prison

Comments are closed.